Muslims WorldWide

Islam-critical French play is huge hit in Hamburg


Islam-critical French play is huge hit in Hamburg

Edgar Selge in Submission at the Deutsches Schauspielhaus in Hamburg. Photo: DPA


Published: 09 Mar 2016

The first German theatre version sold out in the northern city of Hamburg, while in Dresden, birthplace of the Islamophobic PEGIDA street movement, a play premiered last weekend, with a third adaptation planned for Berlin in late April.

“It seems like it’s a very timely story because everybody, each in their own way, picks up on a point of the topic that concerns them,” actor Edgar Selge, who plays the central character Francois in Hamburg’s Deutsches Schauspielhaus theatre, told AFP.

In the monologue play, Selge stands on stage for nearly three hours, embodying an opportunistic and spineless academic, a loner who is slowly seduced by a new life under Islam and becomes a political force who rises to the French presidency.

Selge said that Houellebecq, through this central character, “asks us provocatively: what values do you have in your culture that really mean anything to you?”

The influential weekly Die Zeit said that “‘Submission’ describes how a pre-modern Muslim ideology turns Western society upside down, how women are denied their rights, how acceptance fades for the central values of the West.

“Does that remind you of anything?” it asked.

“Perhaps of the voices that, since New Year’s Eve at the latest, see the refugees as agents of a culture war between the Islamic and Western worlds?”

Germany was shocked by the chaotic scenes on New Year’s Eve in Cologne when a crowd of mostly North African men sexually assaulted or robbed hundreds of women, scenes that heightened fears about Europe’s biggest migrant crisis since World War II.

‘Finger in the wound’

Dresden-born PEGIDA — short for European Patriots against the Islamisation of the Occident — and the right-wing populist Alternative for Germany party have seized on the events, railing against “sex jihadists” and “rapefugees”.

“I think it’s almost impossible to watch this piece in Dresden without thinking of PEGIDA or the AFD,” said director Malte C. Lachmann, who has staged the play in the Baroque capital of Saxony state.

But Lachmann insists that “Submission” is “absolutely not Islamophobic”, as some critics charged in France, but rather that it “really puts the finger into the wound” of modern Western civilisation.

“‘Submission’ is not really about Islam, it’s about us in the West and our torments,” Lachmann told AFP.

Selge agrees, judging that Houellebecq “very accurately captures the detachment and opportunism of our liberal-bourgeois culture”.

“You really need someone who studies how much we value notions that are supposed to mean something to us — like emancipation, democracy, separation of powers, humanism, atheism, a sense of responsibility for the Third World – and he concludes: these are all just phrases, just paper tigers.

“And he challenges us to fill them with new meaning, or to just find new ones.”

‘Selfish detachment’

The only time Selge said he had doubts about the play was after the bloody carnage of the Islamic State group attacks that hit the Paris Bataclan theatre and other targets on November 13.

At the time, “I thought that reality has just caught up with us,” he said. “But in the meantime I have arrived at a new conclusion.

“I think that because the Bataclan attack and Cologne happened — and these are two very different things — and because that paralyses us, and we don’t know how to deal with it, it’s important that theatre provides a space where we can distance ourselves from it, where we can deal with these problems in a playful, even humorous way.”

Lachmann agreed that “it is the essential duty of theatre to confront the world in which we live”.

The main message for Selge is the need to invest more in democracy, which in the novel is threatened by a triumphant yet peaceful Islam, as well as by the selfish detachment of Francois.

“If we don’t start to massively pump money into education and integration, then we can foresee that this society as we know it will go to hell,” he said, voicing support for the liberal refugee policy of German Chancellor Angela Merkel.

“I support her position, but you have to work so that it gains the acceptance of the population. And of course just having this position is not enough, it also has to be financed.”

In an opinion poll published last week, 59 percent of Germans said they are not satisfied with Merkel’s path in the refugee crisis.


8 thoughts on “Islam-critical French play is huge hit in Hamburg

  1. I found the article interesting. The actor was essentially saying that his character switches to Islam, because there is nothing truly left of our culture.

    Things like ‘humanism, atheism, a sense of responsibility for the Third World’, are actually themselves values he claims we hold, but they are in particular fake values which began to be held after our real values became neglected, and ignored.

    Selge said that Houellebecq, through this central character, “asks us provocatively: what values do you have in your culture that really mean anything to you?”

    Indeed, I have discovered that everything I thought I was being taught was true about America is actually dead and buried.


  2. no need for any comment of my own, just gave a ThumbsUp each to Ericka, Michelle, Ex Muslimah and Abdul.

    Al-Donald-hu Akbar !!!


  3. It’s time for Europe to awake up before it is late, look at Lebanon, it was a christian majority country and now it is Muslim terrorist state.


  4. Of course it will be a hit! Produce a play documenting the life of mo (the real life of mo with his fixation for children) that would be a blockbuster!


  5. You fight islam by replying in like kind only in far greater proportion and NOT by such token rubbish. The next Cologne will only be the last IF the perpetrators are killed or badly wounded. History as shown that muslims are bullies and should be treated as such and once this happens they seem far less brave and pushy. THAT IS ALL IT TAKES. It will cost lives but as muslims say that they worship death then let them meet him

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Well done Germany fighting back. Get rid of Merkel and exercise your efficiency in dealing with unsuitable human’s. Might be useful to reopen the concentration camps, house the male moslems until they can be shifted. Killers gassed and burned, cheaper than any other method of exsanguination – after all the equipment is still there. Just deserts for the murder of 6 million Jews and other victims of Nazi Germany.


    • The 6,000,000 figure was created by the vilest of creatures Ilya Ehrenburg.The figures have been changed constantly with the times.300,000 is the Red Cross figure.What about the plan to genocide 70,000,000 Germans?A Jewish plan!


Published under FAIR USE of factual content citing US 17 U.S.C. § 107 fair use protection, Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976 and UK Section 30(1) of the 1988 Act.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s